139 McCauley Avenue

$1,325,000
139 McCauley Avenue, Pocono Pines, PA 18350
139 McCauley Avenue

139 McCauley Avenue

$1,325,000

Historic 7-Bedroom Pocono Pines Short-Term Rental Investment

Currently operating as a short-term rental, this historic Pocono Pines property offers a distinctive combination of historic craftsmanship, modern amenities, and established rental use. Offering over 3,000 square feet of living space, 7 bedrooms, and 2.5 bathrooms across three levels, this distinctive property combines historic craftsmanship, modern amenities, and established short-term rental use.

Built circa 1920 by New York City architect Robert Cleverdon, the home has a story all its own. Chestnut wood salvaged from the British sailing vessel The Queen E II and stone sourced directly from the property, used in the foundation and two fireplaces, reflect the craftsmanship and history that set this home apart. Original woodwork and flooring, a charming Dutch door, and stone fireplaces complement the spacious kitchen, dining room, and multiple living areas. An open front porch and screened rear porch offer inviting spaces to relax and enjoy the wooded surroundings.

Set on over three-quarters of an acre near Lake Naomi, the property features an impressive collection of indoor and outdoor amenities. The theater and game room includes an 85-inch television, poker table, and arcade games. Outdoors, enjoy the hot tub, barrel sauna, pickleball and basketball court, playground, fire pit, and spacious yard with evening lighting. The screened porch and generous outdoor spaces offer additional room to unwind and entertain.

The property's location in Pocono Pines provides access to the area's recreational opportunities and year-round Pocono attractions. Combining historic character, generous accommodations, extensive amenities, and established short-term rental use, this property presents an appealing opportunity for an investor or buyer seeking a distinctive mountain retreat.
Xander  Weidenbaum
Xander Weidenbaum Contact

Features & Amenities

Interior

Total Bedrooms 7
Total Bathrooms 3
Full Bathrooms 2
Half Bathrooms 1
Flooring Carpet, Hardwood, Tile
Fireplace Living Room, Stone
Appliances Electric Range, Refrigerator, Water Heater, Dishwasher, Microwave, Washer, Dryer
Other Interior Features Eat-in Kitchen, Wet Bar, Other

Exterior

Stories 2
Garage Space 1.0
Water Source Well
ROOF Asphalt
Lot Features Level, Wooded
Heat type Heat Pump, Electric
Air Conditioning Central Air
Sewer Septic Tank
Other Exterior Features Basketball Court, Playground, Fire Pit, Private Yard

Area & Lot

Status Sold
Date Sold November 19, 2026
LIVING SPACE 3,415 Sq.Ft.
TOTAL AREA 3,415 Sq.Ft.
LOT SIZE 0.78 Acres
MLS® ID PM-145813
Type Residential
Year Built 1927
Architecture Styles Colonial, Traditional
School District Pocono Mountain

Financial

SALES PRICE $1,325,000
REAL ESTATE TAXES $7,070/yr

Work With Us

Contact us today to find out why so many local homeowners and homebuyers are selecting Redstone Run Realty to help make their move!

CONTACT US

Follow Us on Instagram